Written by Old Bluffer 24th Nov 2005
This teenage fool deserves his death so much. In the midst of a battlefield swarming with human militia and alien tripods, he throws a childish tantrum and runs towards the front line. His father drags him down, and points out they need to look after his 10 year old sister and there's nothing he can do anyway against indestructible 200' tall robotic killing machines. The obstinate youth is adamant though, yelling that he "has to see" and that it is something he "must do". Realising he has sired a waste of space deadbeat, his dad reluctantly lets him run off to get blown up and, sure enough, within moments a mighty explosion which must be some kind of tactical nuke takes out the whole area.
Presumably Spielberg must have received feedback from some pathetic Focus Group for Mothers though, as it was obviously too upsetting to have a young lad die because he stupidly ran into a warzone to "have a look". So we are treated to the age old cliche of having the little oik pop up at the end of the film, without so much as a scratch. The scriptwriters don't even bother to contrive an explanation for how he survived - they probably felt the uplifting ending was more than worth the sacrifice of logic and believability. Which is a shame, as if they'd done their surveys outside of bible belt America, we suspect they would have discovered that at least 95% of people considered it Darwinian Justice that the silly sod got blown up.
I definetly agree with old buffer that this little Dumbo should have been blown up. He knew he was going to die any way if he ran in...........so why? Why did he have to live?
I assumed that Robbie had saved the world by giving the aliens his horrible brain disease.
uh... robbie ferrier doesnt even die. in the last scene it shows him coming out of the house his mother and grandparents sheltered in. he managed to survive... don't try to talk about a movie unless you can at least pretend to get your facts straight.
Did you not see the "Cheating Death" category?
Anyway, Robbie should have died. The moron ran towards a battle where people were dying left and right. Yet he survives at the end?
"Logic leaving the station on track #9. Logic leaving the station on track #9..."
If you noticed, the one category was, "Cheating Death" although I think "Explosion" should have gone along with this, I did think he was blown up until he showed up at the end.
"Explosion" and "Pointless" categories added.
Also, I apologise to the person who embarrassed themself by posting "robbie doesn't even die". You are obviously an utter cretin but I should have mocked you in a more timely fashion, sorry.
> I assumed that Robbie had saved the world by
> giving the aliens his horrible brain disease.
Brilliant.
This is quite possibly the funniest review on this site, and it isn't even a death!
Uhm. All you people that think Robbie should have died.
HAHA. you make me laugh. Get a life, please, and then
maybe you can give your opinions on things that matter.
:]
Mr. Losers,
Why the hostility? We just wanted Robbie to die!
Mr Briggs,
If I were to speculate, i would say the hostility is a combination of factors, usually to do with a lack of power/influence in reality, and so they overcompensate with an alter ego on the internet. Why they would think their opinion is worth anything is a mystery to me, but there you go - if they gets a nibble of a response, i suppose that makes them feel a bit more popular than they really are.
We really need to add a "troll thread" where we can move these posts for posterity....
With regards to Robbie, I guess on some level I could understand his rage, and his desire to fight the aliens. But I severely disliked the way he and Rachel treated Ray, who was only trying to be friendly towards them and protect them.
ROBBIE DID NOT DIE GAY ASSES. WATCH THE END OF THE MOVIE.
and that is why it says halfway through the write up
"So we are treated to the age old cliche of having the little oik pop up at the end of the film, without so much as a scratch."
You're accusing people of not watching the whole movie before commenting on it, yet it is obvious that you are commenting on this death writeup without reading the whole page.
kls:
- Learn to turn the Caps Lock Off
- Learn to think of a better insult than "gay asses", because it makes you look like an idiot.
- Learn to read articles more carefully than just scanning through them.
Maybe you can think about those when your post is deleted.
Why do you guys bother with people like that? Anyone who uses "gay asses" as an insult is nigh-impossible to reason with.
Because we like to prove we can.
Correction, we like to think we can.
I thought it was ridiculous that Robbie didn't die. He was right in the middle of an explosion! Positively ridiculous.
However, if I was to look at it from the perspective of a girl who doesn't care about logic or storyline, I would say it's brilliant that they brought him back. Now they can do a sequel with the ever attractive Justin Chatwin.
>> But, unfortunately, I'm not ignorant enough to look at it in that light. He should've died. The entire world knows it. Alas, a good plot was ruined (at least for me) once again by a cheesy ending involving somebody who obviously cheated death.
-Sunrea