Written by Old Bluffer 13th Jul 2005
Tim Robbins was almost a spark of interest in a film distinguished by a bland and unsympathetic cast of characters. Playing an unhinged survivalist intent on gaining revenge on the alien invaders, we had high hopes of him going out in a Blaze of Glory. He was even toting an axe and shotgun at one point, while his basement shelter was swarming with aliens, but we are sad to report that the predictable death did not occur.
Instead, Tom Cruise stops him going on a berserk blood frenzy and later, once the aliens are all gone, decides to kill him himself behind a closed door. The door is closed so as not to send his irritating daughter (Dakota Fanning, q.v.) into yet another screaming fit.
There was absolutely no need to kill old Ogilvy by the way. The only purpose in staying in the basement was to use it as a base to attack the aliens. If Ferrier wasn't interested in this suicidal plan he could have just taken his hateful whelp and left.
Don't expect DVD grabs for this death as I won't be wasting my money.
I see your point; yet Cruise's decision was motivated by the fact that the Robbins character was expressing a desire to sexually attack Cruise's daughter. Since Cruise can't be sure of his own survial, and since Ogilvy is crazed and may give everything away, Cruise kills him. With tripods everywhere, Cruise couldn't leave with his whelp quite so easily.
A dumb film, still.
Well the guy was insane...you know? He thought he could kill one of those things with a shotgun for God's sake! Besides anyone who discriminates "War of the Worlds" Deserves to be shot and mutilated.
What makes you think Harlan couldn't kill an alien with his shotgun? Or do you mean one of the walker thingies?
This one really needs the addition of the Offscreen Killing category.
Matt - Agreed in full
Nerfmeister - Yeah, I'm pretty sure if he killed one of the things then the others would guess something was wrong and kill him with one of the tripods